|
| |
Ash fusion temperatures give an indication of the softening and melting behavior of
fuel ash. These temperatures are widely cited in fuel specifications for boilers despite a
relatively poor record of correlating with slagging or fouling behavior. Reasons for the
poor predictive behavior include:
 | Fusion temperatures are based on fuel ash whereas deposits commonly are enriched and
depleted in several elements relative to the fuel. |
 | Fusion temperatures are measured over short time periods while heating ash at a rate of
8 +/- 3 ºC (15 +/- 5 ºF) per minute whereas ash deposits typically accumulate for hours
and are formed during cooling relative to the bulk gas temperature. |
 | Fusion temperatures do not account for either boiler design or boiler operation, both of
which strongly influence slagging and fouling behavior. |
 | Fusion behavior changes when samples are allowed to stand at a given temperature. Fusion
temperatures generally significantly decrease if the samples equilibrate at a given
temperature for an hour or so. |
Fusion temperatures at one time were also quite subjectively measured, but this
criticism has been addressed by the development of automated techniques for performing the
measurements that require no intervention by the operator. Despite the shortcomings,
fusion temperatures are valuable guides to the high-temperature behavior of the fuel
inorganic material.
Fusion temperatures typically are measured at four defined points under both reducing
and oxidizing conditions. These are defined as follows:
| Name |
is the temperature at which |
| Initial deformation temperature (IT) |
the point of cone begins to round |
| Softening temperature (ST) also sometimes called the spherical
temperature |
the base of the cone is equal to its height |
| Hemispherical temperature (HT) |
the base of the cone is twice its height |
| Fluid temperature (FT) |
the cone has spread to a fused mass no more than 1.6 mm in
height |
Generally, a temperature under reducing conditions should be equal to or lower than the
corresponding temperature under oxidizing conditions. The difference in these
temperatures generally increases with increasing iron content in the ash. As is
apparent from the definitions above, fusion temperatures should also monotonically
increase in order of IT, ST, HT, FT. Ash fusion temperatures from some of the coals
investigated in the MFC are indicated below.
Ash Fusion Temperatures (°F)
| Fuel
Name |
Initial
Deformation, Reducing |
Hemispherical,
Reducing |
Spherical,
Reducing |
Fluid,
Reducing |
Initial
Deformation, Oxidizing |
Hemispherical,
Oxidizing |
Spherical,
Oxidizing |
Fluid,
Oxidizing |
| Beulah Lignite |
1107.936508 |
1176.031746 |
1190.396825 |
1199.206349 |
1254.518519 |
1292.851852 |
1296.074074 |
1309.148148 |
| Black Thunder |
1160.555556 |
1177.777778 |
1188.888889 |
1210 |
1178.888889 |
1200 |
1209.444444 |
1242.777778 |
| Blind Canyon |
1192.037037 |
1230 |
1298.333333 |
1449.444444 |
1215.740741 |
1240.555556 |
1315.555556 |
1468.148148 |
| Decker |
1124.259259 |
1172.592593 |
1182.962963 |
1200.925926 |
1278.333333 |
1347.222222 |
1355.740741 |
1368.148148 |
| Eagle Butte |
1217.037037 |
1234.259259 |
1238.580247 |
1244.938272 |
1195.617284 |
1212.407407 |
1220.617284 |
1231.481481 |
| Eastern Kentucky |
1620.416667 |
1637.638889 |
1644.166667 |
1648.888889 |
1626.666667 |
1646.666667 |
1648.888889 |
1648.888889 |
| Gascoigne Wood Coal |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
| Hanna Basin |
1196.388889 |
1229.166667 |
1246.388889 |
1281.111111 |
1246.111111 |
1268.611111 |
1287.222222 |
1344.444444 |
| Illinois #6 (1) |
1059.666667 |
1090.333333 |
1154.222222 |
1252.777778 |
1240.944444 |
1254.833333 |
1285.277778 |
1365.833333 |
| Illinois #6 (2) |
1085.666667 |
1117.333333 |
1183.444444 |
1291.666667 |
1256 |
1276.777778 |
1264.666667 |
1341.777778 |
| Kentucky #11 |
1076.111111 |
1109.444444 |
1181.111111 |
1268.333333 |
1267.685185 |
1290 |
1317.777778 |
1341.296296 |
| Kentucky #9 |
1081.778 |
1116 |
1187.889 |
1281.889 |
1272.556 |
1323.111 |
1353.944 |
1385.389 |
| Pittsburgh #8 (1) |
1047.222222 |
1082.222222 |
1178.888889 |
1222.222222 |
1336.666667 |
1372.222222 |
1381.111111 |
1388.888889 |
| Pittsburgh #8 (2) |
1153.703704 |
1242.222222 |
1305.925926 |
1360.37037 |
1355.555556 |
1381.851852 |
1399.074074 |
1428.888889 |
| Pittsburgh #8 (3) |
1084.62963 |
1104.259259 |
1137.592593 |
1229.259259 |
1308.333333 |
1342.037037 |
1368.888889 |
1394.444444 |
| Pittsburgh #8 (4) |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
| Pocahontas #3 |
1191.111111 |
1248.518519 |
1277.592593 |
1331.111111 |
1296.666667 |
1312.962963 |
1337.037037 |
1363.703704 |
| Roland |
1130.185185 |
1155.925926 |
1166.296296 |
1197.592593 |
1166.851852 |
1191.481481 |
1205.37037 |
1243.703704 |
| San Miguel Lignite |
1286.975309 |
1347.716049 |
1415.555556 |
1514.753086 |
1281.049383 |
1333.641975 |
1413.08642 |
1516.728395 |
| Upper Freeport |
1191.790123 |
1269.320988 |
1302.037037 |
1336.358025 |
1339.259259 |
1378.395062 |
1397.96 |
1429.135802 |
| Wyodak |
1182.5 |
1212.083333 |
1224.444444 |
1253.194444 |
1178.888889 |
1206.666667 |
1221.666667 |
1251.527778 |
|